Digital technologies are creating numerous new risks in the field of migration, Bither writes. There are clear dangers that these technologies could be used to discriminate against people or to extend authoritarian practices into the digital sphere. At the same time, digital technologies can also empower individuals and communities across borders, for example by facilitating access to administrative procedures or digital labour markets.
In her essay, the migration and technology expert therefore argues that important decisions about the governance of digital technologies need to be made now. Only then can human dignity, individual freedoms and fundamental human rights be protected.
To achieve this, actors involved in governing migration in an increasingly digital world need to address which technologies are used, how they are deployed and what rules should govern their use. Above all, they need to ask who gets to set those rules.
“In most cases, technology itself cannot tell us whether we should use it. That depends on what we intend to use it for.”
Migration and refugee protection are highly politicised fields, and the impact of technology is strongly dependent on context. Bither argues that only by understanding this context can we distinguish between useful, innovative applications and those that should raise alarm bells. This is particularly relevant because digital identification systems, AI-based automated decision-making and border surveillance are already being used in migration management.
For example, so-called “digital identities” can benefit migrants and refugees by reducing their reliance on paper-based identity documents. However, because these technologies often rely on large biometric databases, there is also a risk that they may be misused for surveillance or the repression of political opponents.
The central argument of Jessica Bither’s essay is therefore that policy frameworks developed to govern digital technologies and AI-based applications more broadly must take into account the specific requirements and risks associated with migration and forced displacement. This aligns with the Robert Bosch Stiftung’s approach of promoting responsible uses of digital technologies in migration and strong safeguards within the emerging digital infrastructure.
Read the full essay here.